Former inmate Alton Mills, whose life sentence was commuted by then-President Barack Obama, has now been charged with three counts of attempted murder. Eight years after being freed, Mills, a former Chicago drug dealer, is accused of violence that may soon escalate to a murder charge.
Arrested in 1993 on federal conspiracy charges tied to a crack cocaine conspiracy, Mills was sentenced to life without parole, mainly due to two prior convictions for possessing less than five grams of crack cocaine.
7 years after Obama commuted his life sentence, Alton Mills shot, gravely wounded woman on Chicago expressway https://t.co/cVbv8TJs7l
— Cernovich (@Cernovich) May 19, 2023
However, Mills’ narrative took an unexpected turn in 2015 when the Obama administration launched a clemency initiative for certain federal inmates. These were non-violent, low-level offenders, primarily those sentenced during the height of the war on drugs. Under this initiative, Mills deemed a low-level offender, won his commutation and subsequent release in 2016.
Once free, Mills seemed to make progress toward rehabilitation. In 2017, the Northwestern Pritzker School of Law reported that Mills had secured a job with the Chicago Transportation Authority’s Second Chance Program, aiming to become a certified diesel mechanic. Even Sen. Dick Durbin (D-IL), a prominent Chicago Democrat, highlighted Mills’ story to advocate for federal prison reform.
Yet, the latest incident tells a different story, one of recidivism and not rehabilitation. As per local investigative news outlet CWBChicago, the early hours of May 14 brought the harrowing news. After a minor traffic disagreement, Mills allegedly fired shots into another vehicle, leaving a woman in critical condition.
This shocking event has raised serious questions about the effectiveness of the clemency initiative. Was Mills’ case, among others, evaluated adequately for potential risks before commutation? Did the initiative have sufficient safeguards to protect society from hardened criminals returning to their old habits?
At this juncture, it’s important to remember that every policy decision has consequences. The decision to grant clemency to individuals like Mills was indeed political, guided by an intention to rectify perceived injustices. Yet, the reality remains that crime isn’t merely a function of punitive laws. Personal responsibility, moral standards, and commitment to change are crucial in reforming offenders.
To put it simply, there is no one-size-fits-all solution for dealing with crime and punishment. While initiatives aimed at second chances and rehabilitative justice are commendable, it’s equally vital to ensure the safety of law-abiding citizens. This incident serves as a cautionary tale and a call for a balance between the urge for social justice and the necessity of public safety.
For now, one fact is undeniable: a woman’s life hangs in the balance because of a decision made eight years ago in the halls of power, illustrating the gravity of such decisions and the ripple effects they can have on society.