The RCMP’s new initiative to create fake online profiles to monitor suspected “extremists” has stirred up a mix of support and criticism. The plan, recently revealed through a CBC report, involves using undercover online accounts to monitor Canadians deemed to pose ideological threats to national security.
According to the RCMP’s internal documents, the project aims to build a “legend” of fake personas to infiltrate suspected extremist groups. This recommendation follows a 2022 Operational Improvement Review, which called for enhanced digital surveillance capabilities to address rising concerns over ideologically motivated violent extremism (IMVE). Officials argue that with online threats potentially leading to real-world incidents, this strategy is essential for modern law enforcement.
The Royal Canadian Mounted Police (RCMP) plans to conduct undercover investigations online by creating fake profiles to identify ideological extremists within Canada. pic.twitter.com/V7TS6UiVs1
— YEGWAVE (@yegwave) November 4, 2024
What constitutes an ideological extremist? 😂
— Drake Cruz (@DrakeCruz83) November 4, 2024
Privacy advocates, however, argue the initiative could compromise Canadians’ privacy rights if left unchecked. Canada’s privacy commissioner has voiced concerns, pointing out that judicial oversight should be required to prevent potential misuse. Critics contend the surveillance could end up targeting lawful dissent rather than criminal activity, sparking worries about overreach and entrapment.
Ezra Levant, publisher at Rebel News, has publicly criticized the program, suggesting it will focus more on monitoring government critics than on targeting real threats. Levant argues that the RCMP could use these resources to investigate violent incidents rather than watch those opposed to government policies. His stance has resonated with other free-speech advocates who question whether the program could unfairly target specific political views.
Better be for the Islamic extremists conducting organized crime here and not grandma & grandpa on Facebook saying they don’t like what’s happening to their country. 😐
— Robin Lee McIntosh (@flatEarther319) November 5, 2024
The RCMP’s document also mentions the necessity of extensive resources, including more IT staff and technology to support the undercover accounts. Proponents of the program claim this expansion is essential for combating modern threats, but critics argue that such efforts need transparency to maintain public trust.
It wont be Khalistani extremists, it will be everyday conservatives. I will bet money on that.#TrudeauDestroyingCanada
— Dr_CaptPatriot (@I_am_mr_patriot) November 5, 2024
With the program moving forward, many Canadians are left questioning whether security will come at the cost of privacy and freedom of expression. Civil rights groups are expected to continue pressuring the RCMP to clarify how it will protect Canadians’ rights while pursuing this controversial surveillance.